The SEOFOMO Newsletter​

May 17, 2026
​Subscribe Now​

Your weekly SEO & AI Search News to Stop the FOMO, read by +44.8K SEOs.
Today's sponsor is Semrush Enterprise & Summer of SEO.
​Ask to advertise here.​

AI Search expands, doesn't replace SEO

This week’s takeaway

Google’s new guidance for optimizing for AI experiences makes something very clear: SEO principles still apply in AI Search.

This is reinforced by Google’s clarification that its existing spam policies also apply to AI Overviews and AI Mode, and by Lily Ray’s analysis showing how AI-generated content manipulation can backfire, hurting performance not only in traditional search, but also in the AI search experiences many sites are now trying to win.

Why it matters

AI Search is changing how users discover, compare, and evaluate brands. But that doesn’t mean the foundations have disappeared.

Being surfaced, cited, recommended, and trusted by AI systems still depends heavily on whether your content is accessible, useful, original, accurate, well-structured, and supported by credible signals across the web.

The risk right now is that parts of the industry treat AI Search optimization as a shortcut: publish more AI-generated content, manipulate mentions, chase citations, or build “GEO” tactics disconnected from actual user value and SEO quality principles.

That’s not only short-sighted. It can create issues across both traditional search and AI search visibility.

What to do

Don’t separate AI Search optimization from SEO principles and quality.

Use AI Search as a reason to raise the bar, not lower it: strengthen technical accessibility, improve content usefulness, make your entity signals clearer, earn credible third-party validation, and ensure that what AI systems can extract about your brand is accurate, differentiated, and trustworthy.

Also, avoid AI-generated content programs whose main purpose is to manipulate visibility rather than satisfy real user needs. If you use AI for content, it should support a strong editorial workflow: expert input, fact-checking, original insights, proprietary data, user validation, and clear usefulness beyond what already exists.

The brands that win in AI Search won’t be the ones that ignore SEO fundamentals. They’ll be the ones that apply them better, across their own site and the wider ecosystem where AI systems learn, cite, and validate information.

Recommended read of the week

Read Lily Ray’s “It Works Until It Doesn't: AI Content Strategies That Backfire” to see what happens when AI content is used as a scale shortcut without enough quality, originality, or validation.

It’s a timely reminder that the same practices that put organic search performance at risk can also undermine the AI Search visibility brands are trying to build.

AI Search optimization starts with SEO fundamentals

​Google Launched a Guide to Optimizing for Generative AI Features on Google Search​

Google

Google has published its official guidance on optimizing for generative AI experiences in Search, including AI Overviews and AI Mode. Going through: how SEO is still relevant for generative AI search, how to apply foundational SEO best practices, myth busting: what you don't need to do, and more.

• Related: Google confirms spam policies apply to AI Overviews and AI Mode by Barry Schwartz​

A useful GA4 addition to help track your AI traffic

​Google Analytics AI Assistant Traffic: Tracks ChatGPT, Gemini & Claude Traffic​

Barry Schwartz / Search Engine Roundtable

Google Analytics has a new AI Assistant channel in Default Channel Group reports for traffic measurement. This allows you to track AI chatbot traffic from ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude.

Google, take note!

​Microsoft announces Citations Dashboard in Microsoft Clarity​

Ihab Rizk / Microsoft

Microsoft has rolled out a Citations dashboard within Microsoft Clarity. The dashboard shows how your content is referenced in AI-generated answers across supported AI experiences by summarizing and aggregating citation activity across: page citations, share of authority, AI referral traffic, and more.

Subscriptions as the replacement

​Condé Nast CEO: Plan As If Search Traffic Will Be Zero​

Matt G. Southern / Search Engine Journal

Roger Lynch told teams to plan as if search traffic would be zero after three years of forecasts that underestimated actual declines. “Every year, our search traffic was down more than we had forecast. So last year I told our teams, ‘Assume there’s no search.’ You have to have your businesses planned as if search is zero”.

How LTM achieved +400% project ROI with Semrush for Enterprise

Global businesses operate under relentless pressure. But LTM Interactive successfully juggled more clients, growing expectations, and tighter margins by consolidating their search operations into Semrush for Enterprise.

After cutting fragmented tools and turning wasted manual work into more value for clients, their teams improved search project ROI +400%. See how Semrush for Enterprise helped enable this.

Scaling content with AI can look like a win, until Google catches up.

​It Works Until It Doesn't: AI Content Strategies That Backfire​

Lily Ray

Lily analyzed 220 domains tracked across the publicly published customer-stories pages of over a dozen AI content platforms. The data shows that scaling content production with AI is not a low-risk strategy for organic search, and that 54% of domains lost 30% or more of their peak organic traffic.

The program is still expanding

​Google quietly gave 54 publishers control over their Discover profiles. Here’s what they did with it.​

Sylvain Deaure, Damien Andell / Search Engine Land

The first systematic analysis of Google's invitation-only enhanced publisher profiles on Discover, based on monitoring 46,926 publishers: Forty-one of the 54 publishers uploaded a banner image.

Useful to look for a consistent directional trend

​Building A GA4 Exploration Report To Measure Recognition Proxies​

Bengü Sarıca Dinçer / Athens SEO

Bengü explains what recognition proxies are, why standard reports won't get you there, and shares practical tips to build them in GA4.

Great advice to choose your own SEO pathway

​Agency, In-House, or Freelance? How to Choose the Right SEO Career for You​

Kelly Stanze / Women in Tech SEO

Kelly shares the benefits, challenges, and career progression opportunities of agency, in-house, and freelance SEO to help you find the right path for you.

Start by creating a training document

​7 Tips for Writing Great Content with ChatGPT or Gemini — Whiteboard Friday [Video]​

Chima Mmeje / Moz

Stop getting garbage content from AI. In this episode of Whiteboard Friday, Chima Mmeje shares 7 actionable tips for writing great content with LLMs by training documents, setting guardrails, and using storytelling.

Learn about ecommerce subverticals AI search findings + recommendations

​Ecommerce AI Search Optimization: What Citation and AI Traffic Patterns Across 5 Subverticals Tell Us About Going Beyond PDPs and PLPs​

Aleyda Solis

I analyze AI citation patterns across 25 leading US ecommerce sites, showing how AI systems cite far more than product and category pages: guides, support content, reviews, communities, YouTube, Reddit, specialist media, and more. Find out how AI citation and click patterns differ in ecommerce, and what this means for your ecommerce AI search optimization.

• Related: Comparing ChatGPT and Google AI Mode across verticals: The top outcome isn't just that the two platforms rely on different source ecosystems, but that they're constantly moving by Aleyda Solis​

Beyond LLMs: Preparing for the Future of AI Agents

​Engineering the SEO Ecosystem for the AI Era​

Gianluca Fiorelli, Aimee Jurenka

Gianluca and Aimee go through how AI is changing SEO strategy. Explore agentic search, building knowledge graphs, and using vibe coding to boost brand visibility.

• Related: From Ranking to Recognition: Building Topic Entities for AI Visibility by Aimee Jurenka​

91% of AI citations show up in only one engine

​The Consensus Gap​

Kevin Indig

Kevin goes through why a blended AEO score hides the only finding that matters, which page types and domains actually travel across engines, and the shift from measuring AI presence to measuring portability.

Reverse-engineer results through prompt and output analysis

​How to reverse-engineer LLM brand visibility and why it matters​

Gus Pelogia

Learn how to analyze AI outputs, uncover visibility gaps, and strengthen your brand’s presence to appear in LLMs and AI search results with Gus.

• ​Director of SEO & AEO at Masse​
• ​Digital Marketing Advisor – Global SEO/GEO at Fedex​
• ​SEO Consultant at DealerOn​
• ​Senior SEO Strategist at Victorious​
• ​Contractor, SEO at Seer Interactive​
• ​Senior SEO Data Analyst at Spokeo​
• ​SEO Manager (AI Search) at ViewEngine​
• ​Freelance SEO / AEO Strategist at SmartBug Media​
• ​B2B Growth Copywriter (Demand Generation) at Sapiens​

The Summer of SEO is BACK ☀️

The Summer of SEO returns on 8 June with a free 10-day email series covering the topics that matter most to ecommerce and in-house SEOs right now.

Each day you'll get one focused, actionable lesson from an experienced SEO practitioner. No fluff, no filler.

This year, SEOFOMO's own Aleyda Solis is among the featured contributors, alongside a lineup of specialists sharing what's actually working in 2026.

Whether you're navigating AI search, rethinking your technical foundations, or looking for fresh ways to grow organic revenue, there's something here for you.

It's completely free.